I can't decide who to spy on myself with - Amazon or Google

We know what smart speaker makers want with our data - do we care?

Listening in: Amazon or Google?
The Ambient is reader-powered. If you click through using links on the site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

Remember kompromat? One of the best words of 2017 is back in the news. It is the Russian art of collecting compromising material - images, audio, video - of individuals to blackmail them with at a later date. And it got me thinking about the always-listening smart speakers in our own homes. We live in peculiar times.

Much of the commentary and explainers have focused on the overall privacy concerns of always-listening speakers which record snippets of what we're saying in our own houses and flats.

Read this: A quick and dirty guide to ambient computing

The divide seems to be between Team Terrified and Team 'Sorry George Orwell, I don't give a fuck' with some of the distinction coming from whether you're a millennial who has already given up control of most of your personal data.

What I've been thinking about, though, since using both a Google Home and Amazon Echo 2 in my home, is this: Say I did decide that a voice-controlled smart home and access to the power of the internet via one short phrase was worth giving a big tech company an ear to all my conversations. Chances are I'd lock myself in with habits, other compatible devices - including Nest or Amazon smart security cameras - and well, sheer laziness. Now is the time to ask - Do I want it to be Amazon or Google? Some considerations...

I can't decide who to spy on myself with - Amazon or Google

What does Google want?

For a comprehensive guide to what Google, Amazon and Apple do with our personal data, read Andrew Williams' feature on how smart speaker data is used in online advertising. (Incidentally Apple seems to be more of an open and shut case of selling us hardware and locking us into its paid for services.) Here I'm thinking more about how this affects us as individuals.

As an interested 'consumer', it's helpful to look at Google and Amazon's ambitions as companies and how this relates to their business models. If you look at the Google Home privacy policy - it has its own specific page - Google tells us in specific, and then more vague, terms what it does with the data.

Push it: The best smart buttons

It uses the data to improve its services - fine. And to protect users from malware - also fine. Then, "on surfaces where we show ads, we use data to show you ads that are relevant and useful". This is Google's business model. All those moonshots I love - balloon internet, mapping the course of human health, in other words Google's ambitions - come from ad sales, targeted ads. I weirdly believe myself a little bit immune to targeted internet ads so I'm down with this. (See also, people who use ad blockers).

Then, the vague one: "and to keep our services free for everyone." That could mean ads or just about anything really. I use Google's services pretty much every waking minute of my day: Chrome, Search, Android, Gmail, Maps, YouTube, Drive, Play Movies & TV, Cardboard. These are free Google services.

It also means Google has a hell of a lot of personal data on me, probably the most of any single company apart from Facebook (including WhatsApp which it owns). But that phrase worries me a little in terms of the business model. Google uses data from Home to keep its services free i.e to make money by other means.

I can't decide who to spy on myself with - Amazon or Google

What does Amazon want?

Amazon seems to me more clear cut: Jeff Bezos wants us to buy more stuff from Amazon (and now, Whole Foods) and make it as frictionless as possible. You know, the Everything Store. That's why you can use Alexa to order stuff from Amazon. But it's worth pointing out you can turn this feature off.

Of course, there will be targeted ad stuff thrown into the mix with Amazon too. And it already tracks web searches. In order to get us to buy more stuff from Amazon.

I already pay for Amazon Prime each month for the privilege of one-day delivery and access to Prime Video - I use both regularly enough to make it worth it. Looking at my Amazon spending, last year November to February I spent £106.88 on Amazon (not including Prime) and this November to February I spent £119.33 so a small rise but not enough to be concerned about. (It's a helpful exercise though, ditto with services like Uber and Deliveroo).

So I'm not too worried.

If you have recently bought an Amazon Echo or another Alexa device (or even those crazy Dash buttons), it might be a useful exercise to calculate your total Amazon spending over the course of three or six months. If it's not going up and up and up, I'd say you're winning.

I can't decide who to spy on myself with - Amazon or Google

Which one is Buy n Large?

This is an important question and the answer is probably Amazon. If you're not familiar with Pixar's Buy n Large, it's the megacorporation from Wall-E, Toy Story 3, Up etc that is partly responsible for the downfall of humanity. I don't want to contribute to that.

The point I'm trying to make is that aside from the price, features and design of the Amazon Echo, Google Home, Sonos One and Apple HomePod (the list goes on), privacy should be on your list of considerations. Not just whether this is something you want in your home full stop but who exactly will be listening (including third-party services) and what they will do with that data. Not just that but what will each company do with the money?

The shift to always-on, ambient computing in our homes, workplaces and cars will be a profound and powerful one. I'm joking around about animated dystopias, sure, but considering that we already use the smartphones and browsers and shopping sites of a handful of big companies, this decision isn't one we should take lightly.

For me as an individual, assuming that when a privacy policy says it won't share my personally identifiable data with other companies it's telling the truth, I'd rather Amazon spy on me than Google as I really do think I'm part immune to advertising. Maybe you're more susceptible and that forms part of your decision. For me, though, Google is one of my absolute favourite companies but it already knows too much.

Are you more comfortable with Amazon or Google listening in on your home? Let us know in the comments.

TAGGED    speakers    amazon    google

Related stories

google Cast it: The Chromecast tips and tricks you need to know
speakers How to reset or reboot your Sonos speakers
smart home The best smart alarm clocks: Voice command devices with Alexa, Google Assistant and more
amazon Amazon Alexa v Google Assistant: Pitting the voices against each other
google The best Google Home and Assistant smart speakers
amazon Amazon Music guide: Everything to know about the streaming service