It's never been harder to be a wireless router. We're asking more and more of our home networking hardware, especially when it comes to wireless connectivity. But Wi-Fi isn't a great way to move a lot of data about; it's a lot slower than using wires and then you've got things like signal strength and interference to think about.
So what's the solution? Well, a Wi-Fi mesh network can help give us more power across our homes. These work using a wireless signal but connect to one another throughout the home to give us better signal strength and higher speeds.
Big explainer: What is a mesh network? Whole home Wi-Fi guide
If you're finding that your house has dead zones where Wi-Fi doesn't work, then one of these kits is for you. Mostly these come as single, double or triple kits that are designed to be put strategically around your home to boost signal strength.
Costing between $150 and $300, they're not cheap, so it's worth looking into which mesh systems work best for you. We've taken our time and tested some of the leading products to find which offers the best overall value and experience.
Home Wi-Fi mesh systems: Considerations before buying
The first thing you need to think about before buying these expensive mesh network systems is just how much you need the coverage in your home. For many people the money might be better spent on one really good home Wi-Fi router. In the test environment we used, a Linksys EA9500 was the pre-existing router, and for the most part delivered decent results.
Mesh networks are very useful in larger homes, or where there's a lot of area to cover. It's also worth considering the materials used in the construction of your home. Modern homes often have internal walls which are not solid brick. This allows Wi-Fi signals to move more easily as the signals are able to pass through them.
However 5GHz Wi-Fi, which offers the best speed, is blocked more easily by any material in their way, even if that's mostly plasterboard. Slower 2.4GHz wireless does a better job with walls, but won't let you stream 4K video, say, and download speeds will be lower.
If you have a very big house then a Wi-Fi mesh network is the way to go, and if your house has solid brick walls then you'll likely see vast improvements too. None of this should put you off, but don't expect wired ethernet performance from any sort of Wi-Fi yet, and if you can cable then you absolutely should.
One final note about speed testing. For simplicity we tested each device individually in the room in which it was placed â an office in this case â and then again as far away from that spot as possible in the master bedroom. These tests used the Speedtest.net app on an iPhone X rather than any internal diagnostic tools in the device apps themselves. The speed tests were done on the same day, and close together to remove any possible environmental or congestion-based inconsistencies.
In this test, only one solution delivered ultra-fast performance with a single device.
Also, bear in mind that this speed test used broadband, so anything over 220Mbps wouldn't be possible as that's the speed our test line maxes out. This isn't a major problem as the majority of people will not be transfering data on their internal networks.
Anyway, onto the main event â here's our roundup of some of the best Wi-Fi mesh systems for your smart home.
The Google Wifi devices are small and well-designed. The major irritation is that, like most of the company's devices, they demand a Google account. Most people reading this might be fine with that. After all, Google already knows us pretty well without the help of its Wifi pucks. However it's worth considering that Google's routers will know every page you look at on the internet, even if you don't land on those pages via Google.
Checking through the "My Activity" section of Google's account information doesn't show a log of things you've done through Google Wifi and the company says in its privacy information that the company does not log this.
Setting up the pair of Wifi pucks was easy in testing. You scan a QR code and the app makes everything else happen. Use one puck to connect to your existing network with a cable, then adding extra devices will cause the app to build your mesh network. This is seamless and really well managed. There's quite a bit of tapping around the app itself, but it's not especially bothersome.
The information in the app is also pretty good. You can perform speed tests to see how the system is working and Google contextualises these with English phrases like "that's lighting fast" â it's pretty user-friendly. You can also restrict access times to family members and boost certain devices for preset times. For example, if you're watching 4K Netflix on a TV you can give it high priority. That's incredibly useful.
There's also guest Wi-Fi if you want to let people use your connection without giving them full access to your network. Naturally, Google also integrates home products that can be controlled through the app. There are a decent number of these and for smart home fans it makes a lot of sense to buy Google products â especially if you're in their ecosystem.
In terms of the overall package, Google delivers something decent. However in testing it was clear that it didnât deliver results as fast as those from most other devices. The only slower product was Velop and not by very much. Now, the point of mesh networks isnât to provide top speed, but to cover your house with a wireless signal. That said, all of these products do the mesh networking thing well, leaving speed as the main distinguishing feature (along with price).
In reality the speed offered here is more than enough for 4K streaming. The only problem youâll have is if two TVs in your house are trying to stream in 4K or other heavy workloads are taking place.
- Well designed and compact
- Dead easy to install
- Good power levels despite small size
- Google's stranglehold on our data
- No web interface, only an app
- Not that cheap
Zyxel Multy X
Man alive, the Multy X hardware is as ugly as its name. The twin pack tested here is pretty bulky and the units themselves will win no awards for beauty. The impression given by these devices is that they're aimed at people who aren't bothered about looks but want a specific feature set. Indeed, the dedicated backhaul in the Multy is good news as it gives dedicated capacity for one Multy to send data back to the router-connected device. This might not be obvious in most circumstances, but under high loads youâll find it useful.
To that end the Multy has four Ethernet sockets. One is used to connect to your cable/ADSL or fibre router, so canât be used for anything else, and is clearly marked as such. This will be excellent if youâre using it to connect to an AV system and need to wire in things like an Apple TV, Shield or games console. There wonât be massive speed advantages to this, but you might find it useful if devices themselves struggle to get a strong signal.
To set the Zyxel Multy X up is really no different to the way you setup the Google Wifi. There's an app which is reasonably easy to find - make sure you search "Zyxel Multy". One thing we noticed was that the app setup is done per phone, this means that if you switch phones you won't be able to configure the system unless you reset it.
Multy supports Amazon Alexa, which lets you disable the guest network, switch off groups at bedtime â aimed at keeping kids in line â and perform a speed test. Itâs handy if youâre building a smart home but youâll need to register for a Zyxel account before it will work.
One interesting thing to note is that the speed test in the Zyxel app is terrible. It doesn't seem able to correctly measure speed. Tests with the Speedtest.net app were much more consistent and the system performs really well. There is a nice signal strength meter too, which can help you position your second device at just the right distance from the primary. Try and get the second somewhere that it can talk to the first, but still give your mesh network more range.
Like many of these products, Multy has a guest network option in the app too. There are options to add devices to either a parental timer, with scheduling to cut off access at set times. There's also a more instant "block" button for situations where you need to stop a device's access to the net.
- Best hardwired connection options
- Serious networking options
- Big, ugly hardware
- App issues
Linksys sent the three device pack of Velop, however because the Zyxel Multy and Google Wifi systems we tested were both two-packs we have omitted the third device for fairness. A twin-pack option is available though â and likewise you can add additional modules to both of those systems too.
The Velop is the best looking of all the mesh devices we tested. A simple enough look, an elongated rectangle, but itâs smart and compact. Putting them at various places around your home wonât attract a lot of attention. It could almost be an air freshener. The unit also has a cable tidy on the bottom to feed in the Ethernet cable (to connect to your main ADSL or fiber modem) and power supply. Itâs neat. Thereâs also a power switch down there and a second Ethernet socket to connect a device directly.
You have to create an account to use Velop. This is annoying and itâs one of three things about this pack that put it bottom of our list. Nothing here is a dismal failure, but given the pricing it feels like your money would be more wisely spent elsewhere â unless the Linksys has other features you want.
One of Velopâs other selling points is that it works with Alexa. This is â as with Multy â a pretty neat idea. However there is a weird feature that allows you to ask Alexa your Velop Wi-Fi password. The only way this can possibly work is if your Wi-Fi password is stored in the cloud â which we know it is from the requirement to have a user account.
This isnât an entirely great idea. While Iâm sure security precautions are taken itâs still worrying. Someone could, in theory, shout âWhatâs my Wi-Fi password?â through your letterbox and listen to the Alexa response. From there theyâre on your wireless network and can access anything.
The app is nice enough, setup is automated as with the others, and it looks nice. There are the usual features, like switching off access to some users at certain times. However during our tests it was possible to put the app into a loop that it couldnât recover from. It seems to be that adding a second network device in without following the correct process was the problem here.
The other issue we discovered was that the Velop had very odd and inconsistent speed test results. The first time we ran them it managed only 90.3Mbps in the same room as the main router. A re-test saw that massively jump to 219Mbps in the office and 164Mbps in the master bedroom. It could be that the system updated itself, or it could be that it's not able to deliver constant results.
- Great looking
- Hassle-free setup process
- Not as fast as the others tested
- Buggy app
- Weird Alexa password issue
BT Whole Home Wi-Fi
The BT system is the cheapest by far, and like the Linksys we had the triple pack to test, but only used two of the three in these tests.
The BT discs, as they are called, are an interesting design. They're not ugly and they aren't pretty. They are interesting and people will ask "what's that?" but they don't look like any other Wi-Fi device.
BT has clearly designed this system to be workable without an app. These devices have a web interface where you can configure them and they come pre-programmed with a username and password. These are secure enough, and generated in a factory somewhere and paired to the device. A little plastic tab is fitted to each which can be removed and given to guests or used to key in passwords to your devices.
Getting more than one disc working is also interesting. You need to plug the second in and connect it to your router at the same time as the first. It will then get its settings from the original disc. This is actually kind of brilliant, as again it means the app isn't a requirement.
That said, the app does help with disc placement and is worth using for the instructions for pairing the devices to make the mesh network. It does also show you clearly which network devices are connected to and it also allows you to group devices so they can be shut down. Kids messing about? Shut off their tablets or Netflix boxes â it's a simple but useful addition. Again, a guest network is on offer here too which is a useful feature.
The only missing thing here is device prioritisation, which can be useful if you need one network product to be given the fastest possible access.
But BT has really understood "normal" customers here. This won't appeal to the router fanatics but it does offer simplicity over everything else.
The BT Whole Home Wi-Fi is the cheapest product tested here. There's also a reassuring familiarity to how the system works â it's just like any BT hub. In terms of speed, it matched all the other devices, maxing out the test broadband.
For all their apps and features the others are left standing by the BT system. BT has a phone app like the rest, but the crucial thing here is that you do not need it. That means this system is instantly more suitable for users who aren't tech-savvy. It is, of course, UK-only though.
- Great price
- Nice design
- Bit basic
- UK only
- Needs BT router