Google might be making the big strides in the smart home right with Assistant and the Google Home, but voice isn't going to solve everything, according to Mark Spates, Google's product lead for smart home.
"If there's anyone here who says voice solves all problems, I'd probably look at them with a smirk, because it doesn‚Äôt," said Spates in a talk at the Connections conference in San Francisco. "Key example: I can‚Äôt say 'Turn on the lights' in the morning when my girlfriend‚Äôs sleeping. I actually maybe want to pull out my phone and do that. If the baby‚Äôs sleeping, I definitely don‚Äôt want to say that."
Read this: Best smart speakers
Spates spoke about some of Google's learnings around the smart home, some of the challenges, and offered up a few pearls of wisdom. "I think homes are probably the most diverse environment to ever design for. It‚Äôs why homes took the longest to come online, because they‚Äôre hard to understand... they're extremely diverse."
In particular, he brushed on some of the limits and dangers of voice and artificial intelligence, particularly with corrective and predictive AI. With corrective - AI watching behaviors and responding - Spates said that it should be "80-85% confident" before it does anything. according to Google's calculations.
"Corrective is us thinking 'No one‚Äôs home, so we're gonna turn off the lights'. No one‚Äôs going to be hurt [if that happens], but wouldn't it be weird that one time your mom and your spouse are sitting there and watching a movie being still and all the lights go off? Does it happen to people in their conference rooms? It happens to me all the time. Every time it happens, I take a video and send it to our engineers and say ‚ÄėThis is what we cannot do‚Äô."
If you look at our smart speaker, everything that‚Äôs inside you could have bought ten years ago
Spates also honed in on hardware, hinting that features like Google Home's voice calling had long been waiting in the wings. "A good example, if you‚Äôre thinking about making a speaker into a phone calling type of device, you‚Äôve got to think about the microphones and the speakers way before you ever launch that feature."
That said, Spates kept underlining how hardware inside these smart speakers pales in comparison to the software and AI, using an anecdote about a meeting between Steve Jobs and Nate Williams, formerly of Google and August, to illustrate the point. "[Steve] holds up the iPhone 'one' and he says ‚ÄėJust so you know, everything in here was built ten decades ago‚Äô. The components never catch up to the user experiences and the actual devices we want to build. If you look at the smart speaker we build, everything that‚Äôs inside that, you could have bought ten years ago. The components always lag."