Zigbee vs Z-Wave: We help you decide which is best for your smart home

What are they and how do they differ?

Zigbee or Z-Wave: Which is best for you?

To ensure all of your smart home gadgets can remain in sync with one another, wireless protocols exist for hubs – and the two biggest names behind this magic are Zigbee and Z-Wave.

Wireless connection is at the heart of these two standards, but there are important differences between the pair to understand before you dive in. Essentially, think of them as two different ways to bypass Wi-Fi or Bluetooth and connect devices, like smart home hubs to lights, and more.

In-depth help: Zigbee guide | Z-Wave guide

Below, we'll go through the big smart home devices compatible with both standards, as well as comparing the benefits of both in action, and helping you decide which is best for your smart home.

Zigbee vs Z-Wave: Two big smart home standards explored

Zigbee vs. Z-Wave: The differences

Before we dive into the devices, we'll take a look at how Zigbee and Z-Wave differ. Yes, they're both mesh networks, but ones that operate quite differently. Here's what you need to know.

Zigbee can connect more devices

Zigbee can support way more devices at a given time – 65,000+ devices, or nodes on the mesh network, in fact. Z-Wave, on the other hand caps out at 232 devices, which, let's face it, is still more than enough for most households.

Zigbee is open

Zigbee is an open standard run by the Zigbee Alliance, whereas Z-Wave is run by Silicon Labs, which has stricter controls to make sure every Z-Wave device works with every Z-Wave controller. The upside to this strict control is reliability, though the downside is a lack of compatibility.

Zigbee allows for more hopping

Zigbee and Z-Wave are both mesh networks – meaning the signals can hop from gadget to gadget around the home and each device or sensor doesn't need to connect to Wi-Fi – but they usually have a central hub which connects to the internet. Z-Wave allows up to four 'hops' between the controller and the device, whereas Zigbee doesn't have a limit.

Z-Wave has better range

Z-Wave has a larger range, at 30m (100 feet), than Zigbee's 10-20 metres (33-66 feet) so it might work better for larger houses and buildings. Z-Wave's latest platform can connect even further, at up to 100m from point to point.

Zigbee and Z-Wave are equal on security

Both Zigbee and Z-Wave use the same AES-128 symmetric encryption and claim that they are safe and secure from hacking. Well, nothing is 100% secure, but it's worth knowing that these two big standards are taking the same robust approach.

Z-Wave is more unified

Zigbee operates on the 915MHz frequency in the US and the 2.4GHz frequency in the UK, which might look familiar, as that's a major frequency for Wi-Fi, too.

One caveat on Zigbee is that it's broken up into several protocols. There's Home Automation, Smart Energy Profile, SEP energy management, Light Link, digital health, home hospital care, and more. Unfortunately, Zigbee devices of different protocols can't exactly talk to each other well.

Read next: Best smart home hubs

Zigbee 3.0, however, unifies all these protocols so that they can work together. Lux, for example, offered the first thermostat to win Zigbee 3.0 approval, allowing it to talk to any device that has a Zigbee badge on it. This is how Z-Wave actually works – it's a unified standard.

Z-Wave operates at the low frequency 918/960 MHz band, meaning interference is minimal for Z-Wave and possible on Zigbee. Still, Zigbee is faster with data rates at 40-250 kbps, versus Z-Wave's 9.6-100kbps.

Z-Wave vs. Zigbee: The devices

Zigbee vs Z-Wave: Two big smart home standards explored

There are slightly more devices compatible with Zigbee – around 2,500 products from 400 members of the Zigbee Alliance.

It supports battery-operated devices and light switches. Z-Wave is doing a mean job of catching up, though, with 2,400 supported devices and more companies signed up – 700 members.

Essential reading: Get started with the smart home

When considering the popular, premium smart home brands and products, we'd say Zigbee slightly has the edge – but which one is best for you depends on what smart home kit you already own and what you're looking to add.

Devices that work with Zigbee

Some well known smart home brands and devices that support Zigbee (otherwise known as Zigbee certified products) include:

  • Philips Hue
  • Samsung SmartThings
  • Amazon Echo Plus (with Alexa for voice controls)
  • Hive Active Heating and accessories
  • Honeywell thermostats
  • Ikea Tradfri
  • Belkin WeMo Link
  • Yale smart locks
  • Sengled smart lights
  • ADT Security Hub
  • Wink hub
  • Somfy blinds and drapery motors
  • GE Appliances
  • LG SmartThinq
  • Lux Konoz

Devices that work with Z-Wave

Many big name brands also support the Z-Wave standard – and you can see all the certified products on the official website. Here are some of the highlights:

  • Samsung SmartThings
  • Wink hub
  • Honeywell thermostats
  • Hogar Milo (with Google Assistant for voice controls)
  • ADT Security Hub
  • August smart locks
  • Yale smart locks
  • Logitech Home Harmony Hub Extender
  • Somfy
  • GE Appliances
  • LG SmartThinq
  • Kwikset smart locks

Zigbee vs Z-Wave: Which is best?

Zigbee vs Z-Wave: Which is best?

It's still not clear whether Zigbee and Z-Wave will grow side by side, or whether one will eventually win out. It's certainly a quieter battle than the one going on between Google and Amazon.

We're only just starting to see smart speakers with Zigbee and Z-Wave built in, but expect to see more. For now, home hubs like Wink and Samsung SmartThings support both standards. You don't actually have to pick either Zigbee and Z-Wave, then, but if you're trying to keep things simple and reliable, you might want to choose a side.

If you're planning to stick to the big names in smart home (perhaps you already have some) and you want a faster connection, Zigbee might be worth considering. For a larger range, potentially more reliable connections and a better chance that all the compatible devices will work with each other, go for Z-Wave.

TAGGED   smart home

Recent stories

smart home SimpliSafe unveils its first smart lock, and it's skinny
smart home Phyn's new smart water sensor will learn about your bad shower habits
smart home Yale's Assure Lever lock review
What do you think?
Reply to
Your comment