Apple HomePod 2 wish list: What we want to see in the next smart speaker

Apple's smart speaker has a lot of room to grow

What we want from the HomePod 2
The Ambient is reader-powered. If you click through using links on the site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

The HomePod, despite its struggles, isn't a one-and-done flash in the pan. It's (most likely) the start of a new product line, and you can bet Apple is working on a sequel. In fact, there are whispers we'll see a new one in 2020. Who knows? It could even happen sooner.

The HomePod may have impressive sound quality, but it also feels partially baked – a first-gen product that has plenty of room to grow. Kind of like, you know, every other first-gen Apple product.

Read this: What we want from Alexa | How Google Assistant can up its game

But what could Apple do to better position its smart speaker among the growing arsenals of Google and Amazon? Here's what we think could take Apple's HomePod to another level.

What we want to see from the HomePod 2

Friendlier design

The design of Apple devices generally don’t change too much between generations, with the company instead parcelling out its design tweaks out over a number of years. However, being able to place a slightly friendlier design in the home seems like a strong place to start with the second generation of HomePod.

It’s not that the original is an abomination, it’s just not overly attractive; a grilled blob in the wide and varied world of smart speakers. Now, granted, this request is probably unfairly based upon the expectation placed on Apple to consistently churn out industry-defining designs (and, of course, it was late to the party here), but the current HomePod just doesn’t really have the look of something fashioned in the halls of Cupertino, in our opinion.

With HomePod 2, we’d like to see a bit more character come to the speaker. Maybe that means more colors, maybe that means a different outer casing and maybe it also means two sizes to choose from: one to rival the mid-range speakers from Amazon and Google with superior sound, and another to continue competing at the top end. Which leads us to…

Make a HomePod Mini

Apple really likes making smaller, slightly more affordable versions of its products – so why not a smaller HomePod? Think about it: a $50 Apple speaker that could outperform the Echo Dot and Google Home Mini on sound. Moreover, every iPhone owner could interact directly via Siri, rather than having to open an app.

Ok, maybe we're being slightly optimistic here. A $50 smart speaker doesn't feel very Apple, even if we can see its competitive advantage. Maybe just a slightly smaller HomePod for, oh, $100?

Reports claim that Apple is at least working on a cheaper version of the HomePod, one that will reduce the number of tweeters down to two (from the current seven) in order to cut back on cost. That speaker is rumored to touch down in 2020.

The week in smart home:

Bluetooth connectivity

Since the HomePod still favors Apple Music, having the option to at least ping things from Bluetooth would be extremely welcome. AirPlay 2 is great, and we get that controlling your smart speaker is typically done through the voice, but connecting to a smartphone would be another option for those who aren’t all-in on Apple’s ecosystem.

Right now, using Spotify on the HomePod is possible, but not with Siri. That may change, as Apple and Spotify are said to be in talks to integrate the music service with Apple's assistant.

Better smart home (and Apple TV) control

This is more of a HomeKit problem than a HomePod problem, we suppose, but right now our Echo and Google Home speakers feel like much better smart home controllers. Since Apple got rid of its requirement for third-party device makers to build in a specific HomeKit chip, it's theoretically easier to make their products Apple-friendly – they just need to roll out a software update. But that will take time.

As for Apple TV… we'll make the case for a HomePod with a screen later, but it's surprising Apple hasn't taken more advantage of better integration here. While you can use the HomePod as an Apple TV speaker, why can't you also use HomePod to control the Apple TV? It would make perfect sense to be able to ask Siri to display information on the TV, or ask it to open an app. Feels like a big miss right now. Again though, this could be something Apple can add to the current HomePod with a software fix.

Go wireless

Siri may not be the sharpest smart assistant our there, but one thing Apple did get right with its first generation HomePod was sound. So, how does it take things up a notch?

Well, by doing something its rivals have yet to: offer the same space-leading sound without the tether of a wire and plug. Unless you’re the owner of multiple HomePods (which isn’t too likely, considering the price), moving the speaker from room to room, like every other wired device, finding an open socket and waiting for it to boot up again is a hassle. You may have the HomePod locked into your bedroom most of the time, but what if you want to move it every night to play music while you cook — annoying, right?

There’s good reason why Amazon, Google and other manufacturers make you plug in — battery life is a major consideration, as well as the drop in sound quality — but just having the option would give potential buyers a reason to favor Apple.

What we want to see from the HomePod 2

Add Thread support

One of the best features of the Echo Plus is that it's got a built-in Zigbee radio that lets you add smart home devices without installing a bunch of hubs. We understand that Apple is big on privacy and security, and that it likely won't turn to either Zigbee or Z-Wave to fuel its smart home, but there is Thread.

Thread is a mesh networking protocol for the smart home, and just like Zigbee and Z-Wave it's used to get all your devices to talk to each other. However, Thread differs in that you don't need a hub, and it also requires smartphone authentication (hello QR codes!). It solves Apple's potential problems.

Other than Nest, there aren't a lot of companies that lean on Thread for their devices, but we imagine that would change quickly if Apple added Thread to the HomePod 2.

Ride the display trend

The hot new smart home trend right now is smart speakers with displays. Amazon was first to this race with the Echo Show, but Google has since joined with Nest Hub and Smart Displays. Apple isn't one to jump on a trend right away, but this particular trend is well suited to its talents.

Look at the checklist of features for smart speakers with displays. Video chat? Apple's got FaceTime. Smart home control? Siri and a customized version of Apple's Home app slot in perfectly there. Casting? AirPlay 2. TV? Apple's got its TV app and upcoming TV+ service. Worried about privacy? Unlike its Silicon Valley brethren, Apple doesn't rely on user data and ads to pay the bills.

If this smart speaker with a display trend is for real, and consumers take to them in droves, then Apple really should consider a display-enabled HomePod. Just bolt an iPad Mini onto a HomePod, and you've got a good start there, Tim.

Your turn

That's what we want for the HomePod 2, but we can't be the only ones who have wishes for Apple's second smart speaker. Sound off in the comments below about what you'd like to see Apple do for its follow-up, or even which of our ideas you think should make the cut.

TAGGED    smart home

Related stories

amazon Smart home privacy: What Amazon, Google and Apple do with your data
smart home Control4's Neeo Remote Control is the fanciest way to take charge of your home
deals Smart home Black Friday 2019 deals: The Ambient predictions
smart home How to ​smarten up your record player with Sonos
amazon Get spooky with Alexa this Halloween, as new skills land
smart home Sony kills PlayStation Vue because digital TV bundles no longer make sense
What do you think?
Reply to
Your comment